Kiss it goodbye.
The Michigan DNR has thrown in the towel on its attempt to purchase the former Dock Property between Eagle Lake and the Juno Chain and create a facility for public use.
“Without support from Ontwa Township, the Department of Natural Resources has decided not to move forward with the acquisition of the Dock parcel on Eagle Lake,” said DNR official Paul Yauk, who has spearheaded the acquisition and development since early spring.
And who can blame the agency? The well-organized lake associations on both bodies of water have fought the DNR vehemently. The DNR said from beginning that it wanted community and local governmental support before it wrote the $600,000 check to 1st Source Bank, who owns the foreclosed property.
It didn’t get that support.
On the surface, this matter may not appear to impact Hoosiers, but it does. The lakes are located a few miles north of Elkhart and have been popular fishing lakes.
More importantly, it exemplifies how difficult and political it has become for state governments to develop public access for all residents.
In this one, many Ontwa government officials – who privately supported the project – buckled and the DNR and sportsmen got bush-wacked.
The deal crumbled this week when the Township Zoning Board of Appeals astonishingly voted 4-3, denying the project was a “park” and therefore didn’t meet township standards for a residential development.
They voted that way despite their own township attorneys and engineers saying that the site met the zoning regulations and was indeed a “park.” Officials led the DNR to believe it had township support and the state could write the check to the bank the next day and take ownership.
Yet, some board members argued there was no playground equipment included in the plan and therefore didn’t qualify as a park. Apparently, without teeter totters and merry-go-rounds, you can’t have a community facility that provides improved boat launching, parking, a community pavilion, restrooms, and a kids’ fishing pond.
Really. I’m not making this stuff up.
Oh, wait, there’s more. Two of the zoning board members who voted against the DNR acquisition reportedly are members of the lake associations that have protested the DNR acquisition from the beginning.
Conflict of interest? You betcha.
The DNR should have appealed the ruling which it could have won easily in court, but got tired of being kicked over a project designed for the good of all Michigan residents. It has other opportunities to develop access sites around the state, so it will take its money elsewhere.
Thanks a lot Ontwa Township.
Of course, lake residents insist they really aren’t opposed to a boat launch, but simply concerned with the inclusion of more people/boats on their lakes. They claim it’s a matter of safety and conservation.
Bull. Why didn’t they offer to work with the DNR instead of fighting them over petty issues?
The Dock property has served as a parking facility for boaters for 50 years and the DNR development would have improved an eyesore. The trailer parking the DNR allotted was less than what was available before the bank took ownership. The project also would have provided the community a safer environment with additional outdoor recreation.
If water safety is a sincere concern, why don’t lake residents address the boat traffic they themselves have created? Many have multiple power boats, Jet Skis, pontoons and sailboats tied their docks. Why not impose a no-wake period in the mornings, as some lakes do?
Because that interferes with their private playground.
If I’m wrong and the lakers have good intentions, they can prove it. Invest the money they reportedly gathered to fight the DNR’s purchase.
They can spend their own cash to improve the existing, dilapidated launch and add a safer parking area for those who still try to use it. Address those traffic concerns that they portrayed in their arguments. Spend their dollars – not the money that state of Michigan and sportsmen were eager to invest.
Bet they won’t. Now that the DNR walked away, those committed dollars likely will disappear. Or, maybe they’ll buy it, invest in residential lots, make money off the deal and stick more docks in the lake for more boats to crowd up THEIR lakes.
Don’t be surprised if that happens.
The DNR certainly isn’t blameless in this travesty. To walk away from such a perfect parcel and beneficial project sets a horrible precedent and sends a message to other well-heeled lake associations that they can hire attorneys and beat down future public access attempts.
Sportsmen and boaters who fund these projects will get the short end of the stick. Again.
Contact Goshen News outdoor writer Louie Stout at email@example.com.
Kiss it goodbye.
- PREP BOYS BASKETBALL: THE FINAL TWO ELKHART -- A grand prize awaits either the Goshen Redskins or Concord Minutemen tonight. Those two long-time high school boys basketball tournament fixtures at North Side gym clash in a Class 4A sectional championship game at 7:30. Goshen was 30-for-
- PREP BOYS BASKETBALL: Warriors hold off Lancers, advance to finals EMMA -- Last season, LaVille eliminated Westview in the championship game of the Class 2A Westview Sectional. For nearly a year, the Warriors have been waiting to pay the Lancers back for that disappointing loss. The bill came due Friday night as the
- PREP BOYS BASKETBALL: Oh, so close ELKHART -- Tradition continued for Concord and history was denied Goshen. The Minutemen trimmed the Redskins, 50-45, Saturday night in a Class 4A high school boys basketball sectional championship game at North Side Gym. It's Concord's 13th sectional
- THE SKINNY: Hoop dreams live on for some "If you put your effort and concentration into playing to your potential, to be the best that you can be, I don't care what the scoreboard says at the end of the game, in my book we're gonna be winners." -- Coach Norman Dale (Gene Hackman), "Hoosiers
- OUTDOOR COLUMN: Owls and more on a trip to northern Minnesota You're going to Northern Minnesota?! Now?! The end of February?! That was the reaction from nearly everyone when I told them I was going to Minnesota last month. "Haven't you had enough of snow and cold in northern Indiana this winter? Why do you, w
- PREP BOYS BASKETBALL: Panthers dispatch Chargers, on to regionals SYRACUSE -- Pail Widner may not have been on the court scoring baskets, but there is no doubt as to the importance his role played in the NorthWood High School boys basketball team winning the Class 3A sectional championship Saturday night at Wawasee
- PREP BOYS BASKETBALL: Warriors win another sectional crown EMMA -- Another year, another Class 2A sectional boys basketball title. Westview made it six sectional crowns in the last 10 seasons Saturday night with a 60-49 win over Bremen in the finals of the Westview Sectional. Despite the seemingly close fin
- OUTDOOR COLUMN: You’ll pay more to fish Michigan this year Hoosiers should be prepared to pay more for Michigan's new fishing licenses that went on sale this month. The 2013-14 licenses remains valid until March 31. The new annual non-resident license will jump from $28 to $76. Michigan has eliminated the re
- COLLEGE BASKETBALL: Robinson pushes Michigan past IU ANN ARBOR, Mich. — Glenn Robinson scored 20 points, including a tie-breaking 3-pointer with 1:10 to play, and Jordan Morgan had a double-double in his final home game to help No. 12 Michigan finish off its Big Ten championship season with an 84-80 victory over Indiana on Saturday night.
- WOMEN'S BASKETBALL: Irish beat NC State in ACCs GREENSBORO, N.C. — Jewell Loyd scored 16 points to help No. 2 Notre Dame beat No. 14 North Carolina State 83-48 in Saturday's Atlantic Coast Conference tournament semifinals. Kayla McBride was among four in double figures with 10 points for the top-
- More Sports Headlines