Goshen News, Goshen, IN

Local News

January 20, 2013

Is the time right for trained teachers to be armed in public schools?

Local educators say, 'no;' sheriff says, 'maybe'

GOSHEN — Following the Dec. 14, 2012 mass shooting at Sandy Hook Elementary School that left 20 children and six teachers dead, debate has been ongoing locally and nationwide on how best to keep schools and their students safe.

Among those leading the debate in Indiana is Republican state Sen. Jim Tomes, who has proposed controversial new legislation that would give teachers the option to carry concealed firearms while in the classroom.

As a backdrop for his proposal, Tomes points to a specific state statute which allows school officials to ban weapons from being brought onto school premises while also allowing an exemption for anyone who has been employed or authorized by education officials “to act as a security guard, perform or participate in a school function, or participate in any other activity authorized by a school.”

While Tomes’ proposal has been slowly gaining traction across the state in recent weeks — bolstered in no small part by a mounting public outcry surrounding the Sandy Hook massacre —  response from local educators to the proposal has been decidedly negative.

A teacher’s role

Diane Woodworth, superintendent of Goshen Community Schools, is included among those local educators who have come out publicly in opposition to Tomes’ proposal.

“I guess I don’t feel like teachers are trained at this point, and even if they were trained, their primary role is not to be a police officer or a first responder, it’s to educate the children,” Woodworth said. “It seems like wherever there are guns, accidents can happen. Often it’s not intentional, but I would just worry about what might happen. I just feel like it would add another whole dimension of safety concerns.”

Barry Younghans, principal of Goshen High School, agreed.

“I think the best thing we can do to help our schools is to know our kids,” Younghans said. “I think knowing our kids and knowing the kinds of struggles they come with will help us identify the kids that are at risk. I think we need to start looking at the whole student. Our job is to help these kids become productive citizens both here in Goshen and in the world, so I don’t think arming our teachers is the way to go.”

The right of defense

Elkhart County’s sheriff, however, thinks teachers with guns may be in a position to halt an assault.

Brad Rogers highlights the same state statute cited by Sen. Tomes.

“Indiana code allows for teachers to be armed if the school authorizes it,” Rogers said. As with any Hoosier, they would have to legally be able to possess a firearm and have a permit.

The sheriff also quoted Article 1, Section 32 of the Indiana Constitution: “The people shall have a right to bear arms, for the defense of themselves and the State.”

“We’re not talking about militia, army,” Rogers said. “...It’s about defending themselves. I will defend people’s right not to carry a firearm. However, I’m also going to defend the right for citizens to carry a firearm.”

As for teachers packing guns in school, Rogers said that’s not a decision for law enforcement.

“It’s a school decision,” Rogers said. “...I’m never going to recommend this because it’s really their call.”

However, the sheriff also termed gun-free zones “kill zones.” And schools are gun-free zones, he said.

“(Homicidal shooters) know there’s nothing to stop them until the police arrive,” Roger said. “They can do a lot of damage in those few minutes. ... The bad guy doesn’t obey the law anyway.”

Rogers isn’t suggesting that everybody has to carry a firearm, but added, “When you have a gun-free zone, it’s a recipe for disaster because people can’t defend themselves.”

Rogers sees potential benefits to having armed teachers. Still, he feels school officials need to be concerned about how teachers would carry and store the weapons, and keep them out of pupils’ hands.

Another element that merits concern, in Rogers’ view, involves the police response to a school shooting.

“You have 12 teachers brandishing guns at a scene. (Police) arrive to go after the shooter,” he offered as an example. With multiple firearms displayed, Rogers said, officers may not know who the enemy is.

“There are logistic issues,” the sheriff said, “we need to partner with schools on.”

Rogers said he’s willing to work with school officials in talking about police response, armed teachers, more police officers on school premises or other security measures.

The sheriff also said that just because a firearm is present in a situation doesn’t mean someone’s going to be shot or killed. For a potential victim, according to Rogers, “oftentimes the presentation of deadly force stops the force.”

Rogers described himself as being very pro-firearm. He also said he has many liberal-thinking friends.

“I consider myself peace-loving,” Rogers said. And he believes in people carrying guns.

“Firearms will oftentimes stop the force and keep law-abiding citizens alive,” he said.

Another way

One alternative to arming teachers that is gaining traction among local educators is a bill being promoted by Indiana Attorney General Greg Zoeller. The proposal would provide more state dollars to local school corporations to put more police officers in schools.

According to Woodworth, Goshen Community Schools currently employs three school resource officers, or SROs, whose presence she says has been a godsend for the schools in which they serve.

“We have one at Goshen High School, one at the middle school and then one who kind of spreads his time out between all the elementary schools,” Woodworth said. “They have been just wonderful. They help us with all of our safety drills and lockdown plans. If there are any issues in the city they let us know. They are just a great resource, so I think all schools could benefit from more of them.”

Dennis VanDuyne, superintendent of the West Noble School Corp., said he also would have no problem throwing his support behind such legislation.

“I would be very supportive of any bill that provided funds for police officers in school,” VanDuyne said. “West Noble is fortunate that we already have two full-time school resource officers, one on each of our campuses. But we would be very grateful for a third officer, even part-time, to circulate among all buildings at random times. It is an option we will investigate even if additional funding is not provided.”

In Kosciusko County, Wawasee Community Schools Superintendent Tom Edington said he has already begun the process of setting up a meeting with local and state law enforcement personnel. The purpose will be to discuss what the corporation is doing right with regards to school safety, and what it can improve.

“We will consider ways to have an increased police presence and more emergency training for our employees,” Edington said. “Wawasee Schools has recently spent hundreds of thousands of dollars installing remote door locking/unlocking hardware and new security camera systems at each school. We have the services of a school resource officer through the Kosciusko County Sheriff’s Department and several school safety specialists trained by the state. An additional school resource officer paid through state tax dollars would be nice.”

 

1
Text Only
Local News
  • Mary Alice Miller SILVERTON, Ore. — Mary Alice Miller, born Aug. 9, 1950, near Topeka, LaGrange County, Ind., departed this life following a short illness Tuesday at her home near Silverton. Mary was baptized in her youth upon confession of her faith in Jesus Christ a

    July 31, 2014

  • Gene R. Lowther ELKHART — Gene R. Lowther, 75, died Tuesday at Golden Living Center. He married Mary M. Flynn March 27, 1970, in Elkhart. She survives with two sons, Michael (Pam) Estes and James Estes, both of Elkhart; and two daughters, Donna Estes of Elkhart and

    July 31, 2014

  • GN140801 jeffery hunt Warsaw man gets 120 years for home invasion

    GOSHEN — An elderly New Paris couple who were victims of a violent home invasion last fall recounted that frightening night during one of their attackers’ sentencing hearing.

    July 31, 2014 1 Photo

  • BIZ GN140801 eby ford image 02 Eby Ford renovates showroom and more GOSHEN — The remodeled and expanded Eby Ford, Lincoln, Mercury dealership was celebrated Thursday night during an open house and ribbon cutting. “Without our awesome customers, we wouldn’t be here,” said owner Todd Eby as he addressed the crowd of fr

    July 31, 2014 2 Photos

  • GN140801 Mackowiak new Millersburg marshal.jpg Retired Goshen police officer sworn in as new Millersburg town marshal

    Retired Goshen police officer Al Mackowiak was sworn in as Millersburg's new town marshal Wednesday.

    July 31, 2014 1 Photo

  • Wawasee Conservancy map Conservancy buys wetlands property at Syracuse Lake SYRACUSE — The Wawasee Area Conservancy Foundation has purchased 44 1/2 acres of property along the southeast corner of Syracuse Lake. It is adjacent to the CSX railroad tracks, East Shore Drive and Cornelius Road and includes the Bonar Lake wetlands

    July 31, 2014 1 Photo

  • GN140731 Habitat auction2.jpg Friday auction to benefit Habitat SHIPSHEWANA — On Friday, LaGrange County Habitat for Humanity will host its annual auction at Shipshewana Auction Barn.The auction begins at 3:30 p.m. and includes, among many other items, a five-piece bedroom suite, a white oak trestle table and a d

    July 31, 2014 1 Photo

  • City heads seek more employees GOSHEN — Like the 2014 budget, the city of Goshen’s proposed 2015 budget will include a number of requests for new personnel as department heads fight to maintain services amidst growing responsibilities and shrinking coffers.The Goshen City Council

    July 31, 2014

  • Rerouting for U.S. 33 lags behind GOSHEN — It looks like the city could start seeing some movement on the planned U.S. 33 rerouting project by as early as next month.That’s the word from Goshen Civil City Engineer Mary Cripe, who spoke on the subject during the annual Goshen City Cou

    July 31, 2014

  • School board OKs contract GOSHEN — The Board of Directors of the Goshen Community School Corp. approved the design-build contract with Ancon Construction of Goshen Wednesday.They approved $12.260 million for the Goshen Middle School piece of construction, said GCS Superintend

    July 31, 2014

Parade
Magazine

Click HERE to read all your Parade favorites including Hollywood Wire, Celebrity interviews and photo galleries, Food recipes and cooking tips, Games and lots more.
Poll

Classes at Goshen Community Schools and St. John the Evangelist Catholic School will begin the 2014-15 school year on Thursday, Aug. 7. School corporations throughout the state have been trending toward earlier start dates the past few years. When do you think school should start?

I think early August is a good time to start
I think later in August would be a good time to start
I think school should start after Labor Day
     View Results
AP Video
Netanyahu Vows to Destroy Hamas Tunnels Obama Slams Republicans Over Lawsuit House Leaders Trade Blame for Inaction Malaysian PM: Stop Fighting in Ukraine Cantor Warns of Instability, Terror in Farewell Ravens' Ray Rice: 'I Made a Huge Mistake' Florida Panther Rebound Upsets Ranchers Small Plane Crash in San Diego Parking Lot Busy Franco's Not Afraid of Overexposure Fighting Blocks Access to Ukraine Crash Site Dangerous Bacteria Kills One in Florida Workers Dig for Survivors After India Landslide Texas Scientists Study Ebola Virus Smartphone Powered Paper Plane Debuts at Airshow Southern Accent Reduction Class Cancelled in TN