Goshen News, Goshen, IN

Local News

September 13, 2011

LaGrange County man feels judge’s sentence of foster mom too lenient

LaGRANGE — At not quite 4:30 p.m. Friday, Tyler Sprunger was busy with a black marker.

The Shipshewana man was bent over the open trunk of a Pontiac Sunfire angle-parked outside the LaGrange County Courthouse. In the car was a sign.

“Just touching it up, filling it in a little bit,” he later explained of his work on the sign, which contained a message he was about to make public. Again.

“77 Days for Murder,” it read.

Friday marked Sprunger’s third time staging a protest outside the courthouse. He wants to send a message about his cousin, Christy Shaffer of Topeka; his niece, 15-month-old Alissa Guernsey; and the judicial system.

Little Alissa is dead. Shaffer was originally sentenced to a prison term in connection with the toddler’s death. A judge later modified that sentence to six months home detention and three years on probation.

That’s not Sprunger’s idea of justice.

Sequence of events

Alissa Guernsey was born Nov. 2, 2007, the daughter of Kelli Sprunger. The child later became a ward of the state and was placed into foster care with Sprunger’s cousin, Christy Shaffer.

Alissa died March 28, 2009, while in Shaffer’s care. According to media accounts, court filings and Tyler Sprunger, the child died of blunt force trauma.

The LaGrange County coroner referred inquiries to the county prosecutor’s office Monday. The prosecutor’s staff hadn’t returned a phone call seeking comment by The News’ deadline.

Tyler Sprunger’s sign aside, Shaffer was never charged with murder. In June 2009, a grand jury indicted Shaffer on two counts of neglect of a dependant, one a Class B felony charge and the other a Class C felony. The grand jury proceedings have been sealed by court order.

Shaffer pleaded guilty to the Class B felony neglect charge in February of this year. On May 25, LaGrange Circuit Court Judge J. Scott VanDerbeck sentenced Shaffer to four years in the Indiana Department of Correction, three years on probation and one year of home monitoring after her release from prison.

Part of VanDerbeck’s sentencing order stated that Shaffer could petition the court for early release after going through the DOC’s Reception Diagnostic Center. This Shaffer did.

On Aug. 11, VanDerbeck modified Shaffer’s sentence, ordering her to complete six months on the court’s home monitoring program followed by three years on probation.

In his order, VanDerbeck found that at the time of the offence, Shaffer had opened her home “and was being a Good Samaritan to a family member in a time of need when a tragic event occurred. There is nothing that can be done to bring back the life of the dependent child victim and there is little added value in penalizing Christy Shaffer or her family further by continuing the period of incarceration.”

Judge VanDerbeck also stated Shaffer has a large family and community that continue to offer support, structure and nourishment.

“She has also been a continuous provider of love and affection to her own biological family,” his order reads.

The judge’s order has proved controversial.

Text Only
Local News
  • GN140424 Emma1 Pioneer Drama Troupe to perform 'Emma' Emma has a gift for getting people together — or so she thinks. Pride and matchmaking gone awry are key to Jane Austen’s “Emma,” which will be brought to theatrical life this weekend by the Pioneer Drama Troupe.

    April 24, 2014 2 Photos

  • GN140423 west goshen dress code 04 West Goshen dress code policy unveiled GOSHEN — Solid color shirts with collars and two to four buttons are the proposed changes for students at Goshen Elementary School with a standardized dress code policy this fall.

    April 24, 2014 1 Photo

  • Michigan Prisoner Escape Michigan murderer arraigned in prison escape that led to manhunt in Elkhart, LaGrange counties

    IONIA, Mich. — A convicted murderer who broke out of a western Michigan prison in February has been arraigned on escape, carjacking and kidnapping charges.

    April 23, 2014 1 Photo

  • GN140423 Wakarusa Musical 3 'A Kid's Life' portrays sudden techno loss WAKARUSA — The young people of our present day society don’t remember ever having lived their lives without some element of electronic gadgetry becoming involved. For them, it would be difficult to fathom the possibility of a world “off the grid.” So the fourth- and fifth-grade students of Wakarusa Elementary School will offer a comedic and chaotic interpretation of such a dilemma with their upcoming musical “A Kid’s Life.”

    April 23, 2014 1 Photo

  • GN140423 stress relief 03 Furry pals help GC students with dog days of finals GOSHEN - Goshen College students took a break from preparing for final exams to hangout with some four-legged friends Monday afternoon.

    April 23, 2014 1 Photo

  • GN140423 FF spring play_3547 Fairfield students to present Oscar Wilde classic BENTON — Fairfield’s musicals and plays have recently left their status as an extracurricular activity and come under the wing of the Performing Arts Department and under the direction of Andrew Muth.

    April 23, 2014 3 Photos

  • Sheriff Brad Rogers_0657 Sheriff travels to Nev. ranch in fed dispute Elkhart County Sheriff Brad Rogers has weighed in on a controversy surrounding a Nevada rancher, and visited the scene of the struggle.

    April 23, 2014 1 Photo

  • GN140209 snow storm 05 Elkhart, LaGrange counties denied FEMA aid GOSHEN — Elkhart and LaGrange counties were not among the 19 Indiana counties that had financial aid approved Tuesday by FEMA for a January winter storm.

    April 23, 2014 1 Photo

  • Prep Roundup BASEBALL Falcons garner road win The Fairfield Falcons posted a 5-4 victory Tuesday evening at Rochester. Dustin Everage (three innings), Andrew Bobeck (three) and Austin Christner (one) pitched for the winners. Everage struck out three to earn the

    April 23, 2014

  • Akela.jpg SLIDESHOW: Pets of the Week Available cats and dogs at the Humane Society of Elkhart County. These loving animals are looking for permanent homes.

    April 22, 2014 1 Photo


Click HERE to read all your Parade favorites including Hollywood Wire, Celebrity interviews and photo galleries, Food recipes and cooking tips, Games and lots more.

There has been discussion at West Goshen Elementary School to require mandatory student uniforms in the future. How do you feel about the prospect of mandatory student uniforms in a public school environment?

I think it’s an excellent idea that is way overdue
I think it’s a bad idea and would be restrictive for students and parents.
     View Results
AP Video