Goshen News, Goshen, IN

Letters to the Editor

December 19, 2012

READER POINT OF VIEW: America’s gun addiction has costs

Every choice we make has a benefit and a cost, and every day we decide if the benefits outweigh the costs or not in connection with our choices. This is also the case with our culture’s decision to allow cheap and easy access to guns and ammunition of all sorts. However, as we have seen in one heartbreaking episode after another, there is a terrible price to pay for that decision. The mass murders at the elementary school in Connecticut are only the latest result of that choice. The 26 Newtown murders — 20 of them children — join a long line of other indescribably horrible mass murders that have taken place at Aurora, Colo., Virginia Tech, the shopping mall in Oregon (a week ago), Columbine High School and the Nuwood factory in Goshen.

One might say that, as sad as these terrible events are, they are simply the “price of freedom” and that all the innocents slain are “collateral damage” that has to be accepted so we can continue to enjoy all the guns we want. Arguments like these are a sign of an irrational addiction. It is past time to declare that the societal cost of cheap and easily accessible guns is more than any sane people can bear and is no longer acceptable.

Here are a few ideas about how to curb this insanity and make better choices:

1. Alcohol and tobacco are recognized as clear threats to health. They are taxed to discourage their consumption; guns and ammunition are also clear threats to health and should also be taxed at a very high rate to discourage ownership of more than a very few guns and bullets per person. That would be completely adequate for personal self-protection and it would gradually reduce the ocean of guns now available. And if bullets cost $100 each, fewer of them would be fired by anybody.

2. Semi-automatic weapons and multiple bullet ammunition clips must be outlawed. This would reduce the horrifying ease with which mass murders are committed. Neither hunting nor self defense requires such weapons. When the 2nd amendment to the Constitution was written guns were muzzle loaded, which required time to reload after each shot so mass murder wasn’t possible by a single individual. The guns protected by the 2nd amendment were only distant cousins of the killing machines we have now. There was a ban on these items until it expired in 2004 — it needs to be renewed and strengthened.

3. Purchasing guns at gun shows needs to come under the same laws for background checks that apply elsewhere.

When a person has an addiction we often put up with it until they start to harm themselves or others. The time to confront our addiction to cheap and easily accessible guns is now. The costs of that addiction are completely intolerable.

— Skip Barnett of Goshen is an associate professor and international student adviser at Goshen College.

Text Only
Letters to the Editor
  • GN140424 Mathis armor NFL:Mathis' leadership paying off for Colts INDIANAPOLIS -- An authentic set of battle armor greeted visitors to Robert Mathis' locker Wednesday at the Indiana Farm Bureau Football Center. The black-and-gold helmet and chest plate look more at home in one of the "300" movies, but they are the

    April 24, 2014 1 Photo

  • LETTERS FOR APRIL 24, 2014: LaCasa rate reduction a big and symbolic step LaCasa rate reduction a big and symbolic step While an ordinance allowing urban chickens was the Goshen City Council action dominating headlines after our April 15 meeting, another action by the council was far more significant: a renegotiated intere

    April 24, 2014

  • No Headline Provided Concord residents have stake in school system There are some residents in Concord Township who feel that the Concord schools referendum does not impact them because they do not have children enrolled in the school system. I would suggest that, in add

    April 23, 2014

  • Letters for April 20, 2014 Think beyond the end of your driveway When our kids were young, we moved to be back in the Concord school district because of what it had to offer our kids. Now as my youngest is set to graduate this spring, the easy thing would be to say that schoo

    April 20, 2014

  • Letters for April 19, 2014 Time to defend Rep. Rebecca Kubacki I cannot sit by and watch Rebecca Kubacki being attacked when she is doing a fine job on our behalf in Indianapolis. Rebecca is an accomplished legislator. In this last session, four of her bills became law. One p

    April 19, 2014

  • Letters for April 18, 2014 Pay-gap percentage is misleading A left-leaning group is claiming that woman earn 77 percent of what men make (The Goshen News April 2). However, by claiming that this happens when a woman does equal work is false. The 77 percent number is the "raw

    April 18, 2014

  • Letters for April 16, 2014 Talking turkey about chickens Let's talk turkey about urban chickens and the continued attempt by the Goshen City Council to pass an ordinance (see article on A1 of today's paper) allowing city residents to raise up to six chickens for their eggs. W

    April 16, 2014

  • Letter to the Editor Homemakers Club gives praise to Boy's and Girl's Club Our Extension Homemakers Club, Four Seasons, recently had the opportunity to visit the Boy's and Girl's Club in Goshen. All of us had the name recognition of Boy's and Girl's Club, but most of u

    April 13, 2014

  • How to survive the bad deeds of others

    How to survive the bad deeds of others Thanks for the editorial about the Martin's Supermarket tragedy in your March 30, 2014 issue. How true, that "normalcy and chaos intersect quickly and without warning. The best we can do is live the best lives

    April 12, 2014

  • President did not tell truth about health care law

    President did not tell truth about health care law In regards to Joann Smith's letter: Ms. Smith states that "good government protects its people and is answerable to them." Brings to mind the 2012 election campaign during which our sitting president

    April 11, 2014


Click HERE to read all your Parade favorites including Hollywood Wire, Celebrity interviews and photo galleries, Food recipes and cooking tips, Games and lots more.
AP Video

There has been discussion at West Goshen Elementary School to require mandatory student uniforms in the future. How do you feel about the prospect of mandatory student uniforms in a public school environment?

I think it’s an excellent idea that is way overdue
I think it’s a bad idea and would be restrictive for students and parents.
     View Results